Select Page
Outdoor vs Indoor Herb Garden

Gardening is an age-old hobby that transcends time and cultures. There’s something deeply fulfilling about nurturing plants and watching them grow. And when those plants are herbs, you’re not only cultivating beauty and connecting with nature, but you’re also producing flavorful additions to your meals. Today, we delve into the world of herb gardening, discussing the differences, pros, and cons of indoor and outdoor herb gardens. Our goal? To empower you to grow a thriving herb garden, no matter your space or climate.

The Basics of Herb Gardening

Each herb comes with unique requirements, thriving best under specific conditions. Two primary factors that dictate these conditions are sunlight and temperature, which naturally differ when we compare indoor and outdoor environments.

An indoor garden gives you control over these elements, while an outdoor garden relies on Mother Nature’s whims. With this in mind, let’s dive deeper into these two garden types.

Outdoor Herb Gardening: Embracing the Great Outdoors

Outdoor herb gardens bask in the full glory of nature, enjoying ample sunlight, fresh air, and room to grow. However, they are subject to seasonal changes, pests, and diseases.

Pros of Outdoor Gardening

1. Natural Sunlight: Most herbs love the sun. An outdoor garden usually provides enough light for herbs to grow healthy and strong.

2. Space: Outside, herbs can spread out and grow to their full size, contributing to a higher yield.

3. Natural Ecosystem: Outdoor gardens benefit from natural pollinators like bees and butterflies, and they often have better access to beneficial insects that can help control pests.

Challenges of Outdoor Gardening

1. Seasonal Changes: Extreme temperatures, rain, or drought can impact your herbs. You’ll need to choose herbs that can withstand your local climate or provide protection when necessary.

2. Pests and Diseases: Outdoor herbs may face more threats from pests and diseases.

3. Maintenance: Outdoor gardens usually require more work. Weeding, watering, and protecting your plants from the weather can take time.

Many herbs like rosemary, thyme, and oregano, known for their hardiness, flourish outdoors. To set up an outdoor herb garden, choose a location that receives at least six hours of sunlight a day. Prepare your soil by ensuring good drainage and the right nutrient balance.

Indoor Herb Gardening: Bringing Nature Inside

An indoor herb garden is an excellent option for those with limited outdoor space or challenging weather conditions. It does, however, come with its own set of considerations.

Benefits of Indoor Gardening

1. Controlled Environment: Indoors, you control the temperature, light, and water your herbs receive.

2. Year-round Growing: You can grow herbs inside any time of the year, making it perfect for those in colder climates.

3. Accessibility: Indoor herbs can be easily accessed for cooking and enjoyed for their beauty every day.

Potential Difficulties of Indoor Gardening

1. Light: Indoor herbs need bright light, often requiring a sunny window or grow lights.

2. Humidity and Air Circulation: Homes often have dry air. Lack of humidity can be a challenge for some herbs.

3. Space: Indoor gardening usually means limited space. You’ll need to consider the size of your plants and the room you have available.

Basil, chives, and parsley are some herbs that typically do well indoors. For successful indoor gardening, choose containers with good drainage, use potting mix designed for indoor plants, and ensure your herbs get at least six hours of sunlight or artificial light daily.

Comparing Indoor and Outdoor Herb Gardening

Outdoor gardening typically yields more substantial plants and a larger harvest, but it also requires more effort to maintain. Indoor gardening allows for more control and year-round growth but may require additional equipment like grow lights.

In the end, your choice will depend on your specific situation. Do you have a spacious backyard and enjoy being outside? An outdoor herb garden may be for you. Do you live in an apartment with lots of natural light? Try your hand at an indoor herb garden. Perhaps a combination of both would suit you best.

No matter where you choose to plant your herbs, the joy and rewards of gardening are boundless. Whether you’re picking fresh basil leaves for your pasta sauce or breathing in the calming scent of lavender, you’ll find that herb gardening brings flavor, beauty, and satisfaction to your life.

We hope this guide serves as a stepping stone on your herb gardening journey. Feel free to share your experiences or ask any questions in the comments below.


Q: What is the difference between an outdoor and indoor herb garden?

A: An outdoor herb garden is grown outside in the soil, while an indoor herb garden is grown in containers, either with soil or hydroponically.

Q: Can I grow herbs indoors?

A: Yes, herbs can be grown indoors using pots, planters, or hydroponic systems.

Q: What do I need to grow herbs indoors?

A: You will need a suitable container, good quality soil or hydroponic nutrients, proper drainage, and enough light for your herbs to thrive.

Q: Do I need a special herb garden kit to grow herbs indoors?

A: No, you can use any suitable container such as a planter or mason jar, but an herb garden kit may provide the necessary components for growing herbs indoors more easily.

Q: Can I grow herbs on a windowsill indoors?

A: Yes, a sunny windowsill facing south is an excellent place to grow herbs indoors.

Q: Do herbs need a lot of light to grow indoors?

A: Yes, herbs need a lot of light to grow indoors. If you do not have a sunny windowsill, consider using a grow light to supplement natural light.

Q: What are the best indoor herb garden systems?

A: The best indoor herb garden kits are ones that provide a self-watering system, proper drainage, and LED lights for optimal growing conditions. Some popular options include the Click and Grow smart garden, indoor herb garden kit, and growing kits.

Q: Do herbs need a lot of water when grown indoors?

A: Herbs do not need a lot of water when grown indoors. They prefer soil that is moist but not waterlogged and should be watered only when the top layer of soil is dry to the touch.

Q: Can all herbs be grown indoors?

A: Most herbs can be grown indoors, but some, like cilantro, prefer direct sunlight and may not grow well indoors unless a grow light is used.

Q: Is it easy to set up an indoor herb garden?

A: Yes, it is relatively easy to set up an indoor herb garden. With a suitable container, good quality soil, and enough light, you can grow herbs year-round with little effort.

Share this Article


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay Connected



Please note that some of the links on this website/blog may be affiliate links. This means that, at no additional cost to you, I may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase.

The information shared by Home Herbalist is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice or treatment. Please ensure your safety by consulting with a healthcare professional before making any changes to your health regimen. Click here to read our full disclaimer.

Eden Brothers Seeds
Herbal Academy Advanced

Subscribe Today

Join our mailing list and download our free 15 page guide to starting a home apothecary.

You have Successfully Subscribed!